Showing posts with label rookie qb watch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rookie qb watch. Show all posts

Saturday, September 27, 2014

2014 Rookie QB Watch: Week 4

By Liam Madigan-Fried

So I feel like I had to eat my words a little bit this week. Two weeks ago, I said that Matt Cassel looked like a solid franchise starter which would lead to Teddy Bridgewater seeing maybe two starts this season, and then last week I said that Blake Bortles wouldn’t see his first start until week six. Still, I can’t even say I care, because in my opinion, this season just got really interesting. We went from one rookie quarterback starting in week one to three lacing up for the first quarter in week four. So without further ado, let's get a closer look at how these guys are shaking things up in the league thus far.

Teddy Bridgewater: Well, the Matt Cassel story that might have been is over, and he’s likely seen his last stint as a starter in the NFL. The tenth-year veteran suffered a foot injury last Sunday versus the New Orleans Saints,  which forced Teddy Bridgewater into making his first NFL game appearance. After the game, MRI’s revealed that Cassel had fractured a number of bones in his foot, and would not be returning for the remainder of the season. So however the timeline for coach Mike Zimmer regarding his new quarterback may have laid out, they’re going to have to speed things up a bit, because ready or not, Bridgewater’s his man for the remainder of the season. Despite not throwing for a single touchdown, Bridgewater gave the Vikings a little glimmer of hope showing some poise in the pocket and going 12 for 20 through the air for 150 yards. If Bridgewater can click in Norv Turner’s offense like he did in the preseason and he can some help in the running game from Matt Asiata and Jerick McKinnon, there’s no reason why Bridgewater shouldn’t be on his way to a good (or at least decent) rookie season.

Derek Carr: Derek Carr made a big statement on Sunday versus the Patriots  when he targeted star cornerback Darrelle Revis’s side of the field a total of six times, completing five of those passes for 63 yards. Carr was obviously not intimidated about testing Revis on Sunday, but unfortunately that could not stop the massive pass rush created by Vince Wilfork and Chandler Jones from affecting him. That relentless pass rush ultimately led to Carr’s first game without a touchdown pass, as well as one interception coming from Wilfork himself. Carr would end the game throwing 21/34 for 174 yards, but it can definitely be argued that Carr got robbed for a score due to a pass interference call on the Patriots on a deep touchdown pass to Andre Holmes. Had Holmes been able to run unobstructed, the tide of the game may have turned in a very different direction for Tom Brady and co. Despite starting their season at 0-3, Carr still continues to improve in some areas-such as his poise in the pocket and defensive reads- yet remains weak in others, particularly when it comes to shoving passes into really, really tight windows, sometimes (and sometimes not) narrowly escaping an interception. Luckily for Carr, other than the whole two-fumbles-in-the-same-play fiasco, James Jones seems to be at least doing his part in contributing to this Oakland offense, leading the team in receptions with 189 yards and two touchdowns. Jones might not be putting up elite receiver numbers, but he has so far proven to be Carr’s best deep threat and red zone option. I still don’t see bright things on the horizon for the Raiders this season, but one thing they’ve got going for them so far is Carr.

Johnny Manziel: Despite their second loss of the season on Sunday to the Baltimore Ravens, the metaphorical scales representing the Browns quarterback debacle seem to be tipping in favor of veteran Brian Hoyer. The Money Manziel package that Browns head coach Mike Pettine has alluded to in numerous press conferences has yet to manifest itself on the field other than a quick three plays two weeks ago versus the Steelers. The Browns last two losses (as well as their one win) have been decided by three points or less, meaning their battling bald man under center has consistently kept them in the game until the very end. Hoyer has looked pretty good so far with a 97.5 passer rating, three touchdowns and no interceptions through the first three games. Like I say week after week, Manziel has talent and he might even belong in the NFL, but Cleveland isn’t looking like the place for him. The reason being, it just wouldn’t make sense to get rid of Hoyer as long as he continues to put up good numbers. If Hoyer can manage to lead the Browns to a winning season this year (unlikely), it’s very possible we could see Manziel offered up to the trading block for a top draft pick in 2015.

Blake Bortles: The Bortles era in Jacksonville is finally here! One of the few things I’m glad to have been proven wrong on is the subject of Blake Bortles redshirt status. Despite what teammates and coaches may have said prior to Sunday, Chad Henne got the boot in the second half on Sunday to make way for the first round pick out of Central Florida. Bortles ended the night going 14/24 for 223 total yards and two touchdown passes in his debut- an impressive showing in what many would call the "garbage pickup" portion of the game. Despite throwing for two interceptions, if you actually watch the game footage you’ll see many of those completions came under pressure and in some pretty tight windows as well (hence the two interceptions). The arm strength of Bortles was also let out of its cage on Sunday, with one particular rocket of a pass hitting Allen Robinson for a first down late in the fourth quarter. Now that Bortles is taking over the starting quarterback job, Henne may have seen his last start in a Jaguars uniform (or any uniform). He may have known it was coming, he probably was just hoping it would be later, rather than sooner. I’m going to make a very bold prediction right now: In two weeks win or lose, Bortles will be in contention for Offensive Rookie of the Year.

Sunday, September 14, 2014

2014 Rookie QB Watch: Week 2

By Liam Madigan-Fried 
Derek Carr: As most analysts and fans alike predicted, Derek Carr didn’t show the poise of an All-Pro right out of the gate despite ending the game with a 94.7 QB rating. However, Carr showed good judgement and flashes of passing brilliance by going 20 for 32 with two touchdown passes in his first game as a pro against the New York Jets. Unfortunately, Carr just couldn’t keep up the consistency much past the first quarter. After throwing for his first NFL touchdown, he went scoreless through the second and third quarters, before finding James Jones in the endzone during the fourth quarter, for his second and final touchdown of the night. It wasn’t a great night for Raider fans who expected to see a revamped offense. Instead, the performance left many people, including myself saying “what the hell happened with Maurice Jones-Drew?” Jones-Drew only ran for 11 yards on 9 carries in his first game for a franchise that he’s supposed to be helping ‘rebuild’ (and I use that term loosely). To make matters worse for the Raiders, Jones-Drew injured his hand late in the Jets game, and is questionable for the upcoming game against Houston. While the Raiders offense underwhelmed, they were not solely to blame for the loss against the Jets. Jets running backs Chris Ivory and Chris Johnson put up a combined 170 yards on the ground- included a 71-yard touchdown run by Ivory that clinched the victory for the Jets. Safe to say the flurry of offseason moves the Raiders made on defense don’t appear to be working as planned. If things continue like this, Carr could find himself on the bench in a week or two. The Raiders have Matt Schaub waiting in the wings and may sit Carr with the blind hope that Schaub can revert back to whatever got him and the Texans to the playoffs in 2012. My prediction is the same as last week, Schaub will give an amatuer-esque performance in his last few chances of being a starter, before the Raiders decide to ditch the vet and develop the rookie instead.

Johnny Manziel: One team whom I think has remained very clear about their intent to develop their star rookie (despite what everybody else has been saying) is the Cleveland Browns with Johnny Manziel. Despite last Sunday’s loss to Pittsburgh, Brian Hoyer and company did not make it easy for the Steelers defense come the second half, garnering 24 unanswered points in total, ending the game at a respectable score of 30-27. There were whispers and rumblings before the game and in the weeks leading up to it, that head coach Mike Pettine would want to use some sort of package to utilize Manziel; well that didn’t happen. As he said before the start of training camp, and I respect him for sticking by it, is that the Browns are not going to let jersey and ticket sales determine their depth chart. If those things are truly not going to be factored into any decisions, Hoyer has made a pretty good case right off the bat as to why he should be the starter- as those 24 points came as the result of four straight scoring drives right after the start of the second half. Hoyer also showed great confidence and production in the up-tempo offense, completing 80.0 percent of his passes from the no-huddle (NFL.com). In closing, don’t expect to see Mr. ‘Money’ Manziel starting anytime soon. I think it’s true that The Browns believe him to be the future of the franchise, but in that regard I don’t think they want to push their baby bird out of the nest just yet. But, Manziel fans beware, this is Cleveland we’re talking about. Hoyer didn’t come to the city as a rookie, therefore he may have some sort of immunity to the the QB curse of the city. So if he plays well over this and maybe even next season, Manziel might get the boot in Cleveland.

Teddy Bridgewater: 32nd overall pick Teddy Bridgewater is patiently waiting for Matt Cassel to step aside and give him his moment in the very small amount of sunlight that Minnesota has to offer. The only thing is, Matt Cassel seems to be hogging it all. Last sunday against the St. Louis Rams, Cassel was 17 for 25 with two touchdowns and no interceptions. Wide receiver Cordarrelle Patterson managed to run for a total of 102 yards on three carries, throwing off a Rams defense who had honed in on Adrian Peterson. Peterson by his usual standards had a pretty tame night, putting up only 75 yards on 21 carries with no touchdowns. Still, Peterson is going to remain the biggest weapon for the Vikings offense this year, and with this revelation of talent on the ground rushing for Patterson last Sunday, the Vikings may have found their bread and butter for the 2014 season. As long as Cassel can stay consistent in his game play and decision making, there’s no reason why he can’t utilize the weapons to make a convincing run at the playoffs this season. As for Bridgewater,  I just don't see him getting a lot of playing this time season. As as long as Cassel continues to play like a franchise quarterback, Bridgewater will remain on the bench. Only thing I can be sure of at this point, is that Bridgewater will definitely see more time than Christian Ponder in 2014.

Blake Bortles: I’ve made no secret that Bortles is my favorite rookie quarterback, and based on last Sundays outcome in which the Jags gave up a 17-0 lead at halftime, it’s looking more and more like we might see him coming off the bench sooner than later. Chad Henne is nothing more than an average game -manager, and despite the fact that sources say the team rallied around him this offseason, his play may end up putting the team in danger of another disastrous season. The points scored in the first half were much more an attribution from spectacular plays made by undrafted rookie Allen Hurns, rather than the skill of the plain bagel quarterback Henne. With wide receiver Cecil Shorts III being held up with injury and Toby Gerhart failing as the work-horse back (42 yards on 18 carries), it seems like any kind of veteran support on the offensive side of the ball is unreliable thus far. What could the Jags do to turn it around? Simple, give it to the rookies. Bortles showed way more prowess in the offseason than any other rookie QB, so much so in fact that had it had come from Johnny Manziel, the anchors of ESPN may have jizzed themselves more than when Lebron won his second straight title. Then there’s rookie wide receivers Hurns and Marqise Lee, who together put up 172 yards receiving and two touchdowns. If veteran tight end Marcedes Lewis gets going, the Jaguars receiving corps could become a big threat to defenses this season. All the Jaguars need to turn things around is a quarterback with a big arm that can make plays and I firmly believes that Bortles is that guy.